I've been investigating all the ins and outs of building an electric car and boy is there a lot to cover.
I have made one critical decision, the clutch. There are a lot of people on either side of the fence on this.
First, with a clutch you have the weight of the clutch plate and all the associated bits and pieces. Roughly 15-20lbs by the time you are done. That can equal more weight for batteries.
Now the advantage of using a clutch is that the car will drive like any other you will drive and thus anyone can get in and drive it without surprise.
Secondly, removing the clutch. So you will save the weight and have more room for batteries, car seats, your collection of cat fancy magazine, whatever you like. But the disadvantage is learning how to drive it. There will be no clutch pedal to work but you will still need the gear shifter. Some people can be confused by this.
Now for the boring sciencey bits explaining why. Some of this may be off by a detail or two for the nitpickers but it's the basic jest of how it work.
With a gasoline engine you have a lot of mass and with that you have momentum. To compensate for this you have a clutch to ease the transition of the crankshaft to the next gear in the transmission, allowing a rough RPM match so the two gears slip in together. Gasoline engines compared to electric motors have a long run down time from gas engaged to idle.
Now with an electric motor it is on or off with no idle and the run down time from power on to free spin/stopped is very quick. Because of this you do not necessarily need a clutch. With the spinning gears in the transmission still going from being in a previously engaged state all you need to do is apply power to the motor to match the RPM's and slip into the next gear. No clutch needed. This is a lot easier to do with an electric motor due to the lower mass and almost non existent momentum compared to a gasoline engine.
You may have heard of this with gasoline engines, some people refer to it as 'hot shifting', 'power shifting' or 'slip shifting' and it is generally done by people who know the ins and outs of their car and the feel of it at specific RPM's.
With the electric motor you have the option of both and to retain the familiarity and the longevity of the gears I am opting to keep the clutch.
Next up, time to decide on the motor and controller.
-Colin.
I have made one critical decision, the clutch. There are a lot of people on either side of the fence on this.
First, with a clutch you have the weight of the clutch plate and all the associated bits and pieces. Roughly 15-20lbs by the time you are done. That can equal more weight for batteries.
Now the advantage of using a clutch is that the car will drive like any other you will drive and thus anyone can get in and drive it without surprise.
Secondly, removing the clutch. So you will save the weight and have more room for batteries, car seats, your collection of cat fancy magazine, whatever you like. But the disadvantage is learning how to drive it. There will be no clutch pedal to work but you will still need the gear shifter. Some people can be confused by this.
Now for the boring sciencey bits explaining why. Some of this may be off by a detail or two for the nitpickers but it's the basic jest of how it work.
With a gasoline engine you have a lot of mass and with that you have momentum. To compensate for this you have a clutch to ease the transition of the crankshaft to the next gear in the transmission, allowing a rough RPM match so the two gears slip in together. Gasoline engines compared to electric motors have a long run down time from gas engaged to idle.
Now with an electric motor it is on or off with no idle and the run down time from power on to free spin/stopped is very quick. Because of this you do not necessarily need a clutch. With the spinning gears in the transmission still going from being in a previously engaged state all you need to do is apply power to the motor to match the RPM's and slip into the next gear. No clutch needed. This is a lot easier to do with an electric motor due to the lower mass and almost non existent momentum compared to a gasoline engine.
You may have heard of this with gasoline engines, some people refer to it as 'hot shifting', 'power shifting' or 'slip shifting' and it is generally done by people who know the ins and outs of their car and the feel of it at specific RPM's.
With the electric motor you have the option of both and to retain the familiarity and the longevity of the gears I am opting to keep the clutch.
Next up, time to decide on the motor and controller.
-Colin.


